Ask the Alchemist #3

Do I have to use granulated cane sugar to make chocolate? What about refining with alternative sweeteners or making unsweetened milk chocolate?
Well, first and foremost, there is a ton of information over in the forum about this.

Next, there are actually quite a few alternative sugars you can use, to a greater or lesser degree and success.  In addition to the classic, sucrose, you can if you desire use maltose (or just malt, or dry malt extract DME if you are brewer), fructose, galactose, etc.  If you can find them in granular form, you can use them.  Why granular?  Well, it’s not so much that you want granular for it’s own sake, but you do not want “powdered” sugar per se.  Why, well, again it is not so much that it is powdered but very often something like corn starch is added to powdered sugars to keep them from caking and you don’t  want those starches and binders in your chocolate because it has a tendency to make it gummy and/or oddly textured.As for ‘alternative sweeteners’ or maybe what would be termed artificial sweeteners, the ones usually used are compounds called sugar alcohols.  You can identify them most of the time because they end in -tol.  As in xyitol, erythritol, maltitiol (the alcohol of malt above) etc.  But there are others, used for other reasons.  Inulin is a good example. Now, before we get into this, be aware in can be overwhelming.  There IS NOT one simple answer.   Chocolate is pretty simple.  Sugar free chocolate is not.

That said, I found the following response in the forum:

The main reason you’re looking at looking to use inulin with it is because erythritol (etoh) has a very negative heat of solution (-43j if i remember) – which means it’s extracts heat from your mouth when it dissolves, and that’s what makes it feel cool. Inulin has a slightly positive heat of solution. However, as with everything, there are pluses and minuses. Inulin comes in many shapes and sizes – go with the long chain inulin to minimize gas production. You’ll not be able to put enough inulin into it to erase the cooling of the erythritol. look at some other polyol’s to mix into it to cut the level of erythritol. erythritol, molecularly, is 3x smaller than tyipcal polyols – which means it’s handled by your kidneys for as it’s small enough to pass the intestinal barrier and enter your blood stream (other polyols are just the opposite). this means you’ll pee it out. sorry to be blunt. most work i’ve done on it suggests 0.3g/kg of body weight for say maltitol is tolerated well, vs erythritol which is up towards 0.8g/kg body weight for bolus dose situation.”

Ok, hopefully I did not lose you there.  If I did, the summary is this.  There is no perfect artificial sweetener that you can just use in place of sugar.  Some cool your mouth.  Some heat your mouth.  Some have diuretic effects.  Some have laxative effects.  Some taste bad.  And honestly, I have not played with these sweeteners much at all.  Maybe someday I will.  Right now (and I know this can’t work for some people) I simply take the adage “moderation in all things” and don’t find a bite of chocolate with standard sucrose every few days that bad.  But that is a conversation for another time.  This is about what you can use.Moving on.  Stevia seems to come up a bit.  I personally don’t care for the flavor.  But some people do.  So, putting flavor aside, Stevia is very sweet.  As in 300-500 times sweeter than sucrose.  Meaning you need very little.  But that in itself can be an issue where we have become used to a particular texture and mouth feel to chocolate, and 100% dark chocolate is too hard.  Sugar ‘bulks’ out chocolate.  It dissolves in the mouth.  If you were to try adding Stevia to 1 lb of chocolate you would use very little.  For instance, in 1 lb of 70% chocolate, you need about 5 oz of sucrose.  But only 0.016 oz or about 0.5 grams of Stevia in theory to get the same sweetness.  Like half a teaspoon if that.  And I say theory, because I’ve not tried this.  Now, I recall a Stevia product that bulks up the product, so that it is very close to sucrose in regards to how sweet it is per volume.  Meaning I think you might be able to add it as a straight substitute for sucrose and get something workable.

So, you don’t have an issue with actual sugars, but don’t want highly refined sugars.  I won’t get into the political, sociological, spiritual, health or other reasons you might have for not using sucrose and just deal with the item at hand.  Date sugar, coconut sugar, brown sugar etc.  Generally speaking, you can use any and all of these, BUT many of them contain a good bit of moisture and you know water and chocolate do NOT get along.  See the FAQ if you don’t know.  What that means is you may need (or not) to dry these in the oven for some length of time (30 minutes to 2 hours) to make them suitable (i.e. it won’t seize) for adding to your chocolate.  But basically, they are fine, and have fun.Finally, the other ‘other’ sweeteners.  Syrups.  Honey, agave, etc.  NO.  Clear enough?  NO.  How’s that?  Water!  NO!. Clear?  Good.  Now, more detail.

Under no circumstances can you add any water based sweeteners to a Melanger.  The sheer will just cause it to seize up.  But, you have seen chocolate sweetened with agave or honey?  Well, I have seen both of these at various times as fully dehydrated granules.   But that isn’t quite what we are talking about here, in this paragraph.  I have spoken with some people that have used honey and agave syrup in their finished chocolate.  I started to say ‘successfully’ but changed my mind.  What they ended up with resembled chocolate, but I found it was not quite ‘right’.  Most likely it was the odd or lack of temper.  The water content disrupted the tempering.  Also, I tend to be a purist, and found the other flavors (honey, agave and such) distracting to the flavor of the chocolate.  It was not bad, but not classic chocolate either (at least to me).  So, now I go back and say ‘sure, you can use honey’ BUT it may not (and probably will not be) classic chooclate.  It will be more fudge like.  Less snap.  Etc.  And when you incorporate it, stir VERY gently.  Not using the Melanger still stands.  At least that is what I was told.   They stirred very gently, added extra cocoa butter to keep it flowing and did not rush it.In summary.  You can use other sweeteners.

  • You can use other refined sugars, but you will probably have to adjust the amount you use because they vary in sweetness.
  • You can use alternative sweeteners, but you will have to experiment.
  • You can use alternative sugars, but may need to dry them.
  • You can NOT use water based sweeteners and get classic chocolate, but can use them if you don’t mind ‘something different’.

And as a final closing thought…I’ve tried and like quite a bit, unsweetened milk chocolate.  The lactose in the milk does give a touch of sweetness and is an interesting and refreshing change to sweet chocolate.

Leave a Reply



Articles and other Helpful pages

Alchemical Formulations

buy glucotrol xl extended release buy aceon place cheap viagra soft london cheap cialis nz buy azulfidine cheap buy generic bystolic clomid discount in uk buy wellbutrin sr online buy ventolin pills order rogaine 5 reviews cheap brand levitra online buy zyvox in europe cheap ortho tri cyclen hormone levels cheap renovation ideas estrace discount vouchers cheap diclofenac gel for solar keratosis buy viagra super active to take buy generic zovirax ointment order effexor xr buy voveran sr india buy baytril for birds order anti fungal herbs for candida order singulair in canada buy cheap arimidex online endep discount vouchers buy dipyridamole in thailand buy seroquel zealand propranolol to buy uk buy deltasone liquid cleocin gel discount rosacea imuran discount buy buy arava veterinary order zovirax by mail buy lexapro brand name buy albendazole canada buy cabergoline usa buy maxalt vegas order abilify reviews buy phenergan qtc cheap levitra professional effects men;s health discount eating plan buy inderal canada buy ginette 35 for pcos roxithromycin discount code buy viagra soft south africa online buy generic yasmin online buy valacyclovir australia cheap vasotec version rocaltrol discount buy tretinoin 0 05 usp buy xalatan real cheap hair loss vitamin d deficiency cheap artane motels buy amitriptyline online order female viagra online buy coumadin africa buy unique hoodia zebeta discount order colchicine dosage buy brand viagra uk cheap ortho tri cyclen yaz cheap shuddha guggulu capsules buy revatio ebay cheap diclofenac gel cost buy female cialis online order levitra professional paypal cheap muscle relaxant qualities buy alavert shoes cheap malegra dxt hacks order kesar mango online discount on singulair prescription buy robaxin canada order glucotrol xl nedir buy ventolin japan order cialis soft unterschied buy l tryptophan dosage for sleep buy hydrochlorothiazide japan order clonidine in canada buy xxtra clean cheap v gel opi gel buy zyloprim india buy innopran xl gsk order levitra professional mg effexor xr cost without insurance buy albenza dosage cheap cialis soft how to take rumalaya forte discount zel buy saw palmetto kapsule cena cheap eurax buy cialis soft discount prescription mango package deals order cialis soft originale viagra jelly discount generic buy brand viagra kong buy lexapro xanax cheap viagra jelly how to use order cialis soft kaufen bystolic prescription savings card cheap inderal uk order hair loss in pregnancy buy emsam germany buy tamoxifen citrate uk order cialis super active tadalafil 20mg buy septilin online india order oral lamisil cheap femara online cheap floxin bula buy rosuvastatin liquid cheap actoplus met rx cheap cytotec for sale buy kamagra oral jelly vanilla cheap zofran zydis order pain relief of sciatica cheap graphic tank tops order actoplus met name cheap status anxiety wallets buy rogaine 2 order aciphex prescription buy cytotec xertigny shuddha guggulu discount weight loss order zero reaction order zofran qt tinidazole discount vouchers order pain relief real time cheap urispas price cheap mentat ds syrup benefits order weight loss body wraps dostinex discount coupon cheap cialis super active mg buy singulair korea buy men;s health issues order ventolin inhaler cheap nizoral buy anti fungal diet what to eat zanaflex discount buy buy ginseng at walgreens ventolin hfa discount coupon buy phenergan liquid cheap viagra professional info cheap flagyl er cheap muscle relaxant for neck pain order entocort nausea order cardizem use celadrin discount online cheap claritin d order minocycline side buy glucotrol xl label buy xenical online buy l-tryptophan in ireland gas x cheap tetracycline backorder buy pariet kaina viagra professional discount canadian pharmacy cheap avalide price buy elavil in canada buy lipitor vancouver cheap cefixime cheap flagyl er tablets retin a 0 05 discount krem 30 g order doxycycline rats buy men;s health ipad order atorlip-20 order cialis professional benefits buy alli hk buy cheap premarin online diclofenac gel discount otc lisinopril discount card order propranolol prescription order glucophage illegal order cleocin gel acne reviews cheap rumalaya gel uses buy tinidazole over the counter order clomid pills online order clonidine australia buy viagra jelly jakarta cheap anafranil yawn hair loss discount home remedies cheap generic kamagra uk order erectile dysfunction lisinopril buy rosuvastatin kong cheap retino-a cream 0 05 gel buy cialis singapore order levitra professional es hair loss discount xarelto order remeron buy propecia ebay lopid discount buy anti fungal lozenges buy glucotrol xl vs metformin order lasix canada order female viagra from india cholesterol lowering discount cookbooks chloromycetin discount coupon order brand levitra pharmacy cheap toprol xl drug interactions order clonidine side cheap advair diskus generic buy levlen ed australia buy penegra online innopran xl discount for tremors eli lilly cymbalta discounts levitra professional discount que es cheap anti viral boot cd buy olanzapine side buy amitriptyline best place cheap viagra jelly in uk order terramycin dogs cheap hair loss with chemo effexor xr discount jittery order pamelor valor hair loss discount medication rumalaya forte discount dosage order erectile dysfunction kansas city buy glucotrol xl reviews skin care order toner cheap hair loss yoga cheap benicar lawsuit cheap wellbutrin sr zoloft cheap atorlip 20 price buy zyprexa online cheap rental places cheap isoptin a prescription order effexor xr ingredients buy amitriptyline uk cheap cytotec online kamagra gold discount blister order glucotrol xl with metformin order abilify buy propecia sydney benfotiamine discount code buy atorlip 20 price buy xalatan liquid buy zithromax z-pak online cheap cialis super active vs professional order lexapro xanax cheap atorlip 20 what is atorlip-20 buy cheap zyban online buy desyrel australia cheap finpecia goa liv 52 discount q es cheap indinavir alternatives buy zithromax powder clindamycin cheap online buy actos kong cheap rental textbooks cheap requip a prescription order propecia uk order cialis super active description buy malegra fxt mexico buy betnovate cream uk buy cholesterol lowering herbs order cialis professional testimonials buy revatio kong order cardizem back buy zanaflex erowid buy levitra plus que cialis cheap nizagara tablets order serevent a prescription buy female cialis london buy alphagan online order metformin zealand cheap norvasc generic buy raglan tee order viagra plus legal vantin discounts buy tenormin online buy mircette order mangosteen buy didronel pills order toprol xl long term side effects cheap viagra online usa brand cialis discount buy online buy hoodia patch buy kamagra chewable soft buy dilantin angeles buy naprosyn mg unison discount vauxhall cars buy periactin tablets cheap suprax fi buy levitra south africa alavert discount employee buy requip in stores buy prednisolone in australia order topamax tablets cheap advair diskus msds order cardura zamiennik sleep aid discount juice order cialis soft sublingual cheap quibron t sr tablets cheap cialis soft side effects order lipitor side cheap minocin buy neurontin xr order cialis super active cialis minocycline discount card cheap rental key west sleep aids discount herbal order benzac kruidvat buy avodart in canada order antabuse vegas fluoxetine discount generic order diflucan dosage buy tamoxifen uk cheap vasotec india order diclofenac gel order hytrin dose buy generic femara buy levitra plus paypal order cialis super active wikipedia buy brand viagra bangkok buy levitra plus usa order promethazine with codeine online cheap anafranil wiki order paroxetine illegal etodolac discount prescription buy deltasone tablets buy zithromax thailand buy citalopram online in the uk cheap female cialis a prescription buy saw palmetto receding hairline cheap singulair a prescription buy cholesterol lowering foods list buy vpxl italia cheap penis enlargement buy colchicine canada cheap nizagara information cheap albenza results order provigil canada order lamisil pills online sleep aid discount video wellbutrin sr discount nightmares buy brand viagra zealand cheap cholesterol lowering supplements cheap mircette ocp buy capoten in stores buy requip from uk cheap hytrin uses order bactroban zalf order ralista buy albenza korea order viagra super active citrate) cheap effexor xr weight loss buy lisinopril 20 mg online buy anti fungal xylitol cheap viagra jelly pills uk order naprosyn nedir cheap hair loss kidney disease benicar savings plan buy tulasi plant online bangalore cheap actoplus met classification order lopid jumeaux cheap villas in calan porter menorca asacol tablets buy benzac ac order order carafate liquid order suhagra dosage cheap levaquin uses allegra discount generic order depression xanax buy brand viagra delivery order levitra zealand cheap diclofenac gel y lactancia buy elocon flagyl er discount what does cheap azulfidine ra lipitor discount voucher buy dipyridamole from canada viagra professional discount italia order brand levitra canada buy cystone tablets order amantadine a prescription xalatan purchase uk cheap v gel et tube cheap zovirax a prescription kamagra prix discount buy kamagra soft paypal order requip mexico antivert discount coupon buy aceon in uk buy topamax online cheap buy capoten philippines order compazine qtc cheap fml forte liquifilm 0.25 diclofenac gel discount usa cheap apcalis sx kaufen cheap actoplus met and weight loss cheap alli capsules buy zanaflex cream cheap rental nyc order torsemide lasix order pilex himalaya cheap cholesterol lowering zealand buy tenormin zealand buy accutane steroids buy prednisone in usa buy voveran sr salt cheap cleocin gel vs lotion buy alli diet pills buy femara zealand order zanaflex can u cheap vasotec uk lariam discount get buy tamoxifen citrate liquid buy mobic online cheap viagra super active information ortho tri cyclen discount kong inderal discount coupon cialis super active discount hub order buy ventolin kuala lumpur order clomid volga bulgaria buy baytril for rats buy emsam in ireland kamagra gold discount malaysia alli discount loss pills online buy cytotec now order levitra from canada buy revia from uk triamterene discount code cheap anti viral quick heal antivirus free download cheap clomid cheap buy men;s health garcinia cambogia buy nizagara online uk zithromax discount generic cheap apcalis sx nebenwirkungen order alphagan bula order hair loss yoga order proactiv skin care buy atorlip 20 in india order a bank statement buy robaxin cheap zithromax order tretinoin 0 05 italok cheap effexor xr patient assistance buy clomid vietnam order pravachol illegal cheap v gel himalaya order finalization buy propecia dr fox cheap muscle relaxant for tmj cheap levitra plus online buy accutane singapore order premarin dosage viagra professional discount buy online cheap kamagra oral jelly dosage buy zenegra pills erexin v discount opinie o order cialis professional avis buy revatio tablete cheap indinavir buy online bactrim discount voucher buy moduretic uses etodolac discount pharmacy order brand amoxil name cheap cytotec pills online buy atorlip 20 de 20 mg buy valtrex pills online cheap elimite buy antivert vegas cheap risperdal online buy dutas where can shuddha guggulu discount and ayurslim buy tinidazole chloromycetin discount price cheap renovation tips buy viagra soft and cialis online buy second hand graphics card india generic cialis soft tabs cheap levitra in usa buy bupropion sr 150 mg order viagra plus by mail buy eurax lotion buy amantadine uk effexor xr discount erowid cheap zyvox generic buy cleocin gel insert cheap advair diskus joint pain cheap adalat episode buy kamagra oral jelly zealand order pain relief rotator cuff order v gel jell buy kamagra oral jelly south africa cheap urispas prescription order pariet obat buy urispas from uk buy haridra benefits order weight loss liquid diet discount nolvadex pravachol discount voucher cheap lariam india order benfotiamine glycation trial erection packs 1 discount mall buy compazine purchase zanaflex online order dramamine girl order clozaril guidelines buy maxalt mlt order zenegra price buy erythromycin vancouver cheap prandin in usa buy sertraline tablets