Chocolate and Water FAQ

Aside from wanting to know if there is a piece of equipment that can be used in lieu of the Melangers to refine chocolate, my most common question is about water and its place (or lack there of) in chocolate making. Usually this train of thought goes hand in hand with the Melanger question and goes something like this.

“If I use just a little bit of water, shouldn’t I be able to dissolve the sugar and mix it with the chocolate and then I don’t need the Melanger?”

Variations of this are “can I use honey, or agave syrup or something like that?”

My basic answer to these questions are “No, it just doesn’t quite work that way. If you add water to chocolate in general it will seize and you will end up with a thick fudge like chocolate product, but not really standard chocolate than can be tempered”. I have posed this question to a few other people just to make sure I was not missing something. So, here is a bit more of the specifics of why you really can’t add water to chocolate successfully.

——

If there was any practical way to get water into chocolate, it would be done commercially on a mass basis. Water is cheap and nutritionally perfect. Water in a chocolate system raises a lot of complex concerns:

1) Blending water and oil means you’re making an emulsion. This means the opacity of the chocolate and viscosity will be affected. Think about mayonnaise.

2) Cacao is a rich source of insoluble but water absorbent fibers (cellulose, primarily) which tends to cause the particles to draw in the water and swell up, further disrupting the texture. The cacao particles then tend to push away the cocoa butter.

3) Adding water means many new enzymes that were perhaps previously inactive due to lack of water can become active – remember, many enzymes work in non-aqueous systems with as little as 3-5% water. Adding a large amount of water (or water in the absence of sugar) could lead to issues with water activity and microbial concerns.

4) The presence of liquids will weaken or disrupt the tempering process and alter the texture of the cooled product. Depending on the amount and size of the water droplets, this can vary from making the chocolate softer to totally crumbly and impossible to temper to making ganache.

Adding emulsifiers can help blend the water with the oil better, keeping it in smaller particles. This helps reduce problems 2 and 4 a lot, but tends to cause an increase in the viscosity of the system, potentially worsening problem 1. For these purposes, lecithin is an alright emulsifier, PGPR works even better, and there are tons of there emulsifiers out there (mono & diglycerides, datem, etc. come to mind as solid water in oil emulsifiers). If you can add the liquid directly to the fat and emulsifier and blend agressively, sans cacao solids, it is better as you break the water up into smaller particles.

Using liquids that are mostly dissolved solids is also a good move, as they are slightly less lipophobic. This is where corn syrup, honey, etc. come in. The added viscosity also can tend to make the solution more stable, by interfering with surface tension and making it more difficult for droplets to re-agglomerate. Just think about trying tomix honey and butter versus water and butter.

But, bottom line, it IS possible to make a sort dark chocolate like substance using something like a thick agave syrup. You use a lot more cocoa butter and not too much agave syrup, and the end chocolate is softer and doesn’t develop a true temper/snap as you’d like… but it DOES work, and it sot of tempers. The same concept applies to any kind of similar syrup. The trick is careful incorporation, not using too much and understanding that the chocolate is going to be fundamentally different in nature. You also want to use plenty of lecithin here.

A few extra emulsifiers added could help yield a bit more stable product, but it’s not going to really perform any kind of magic. A few companies have been experimenting with ways to make 1 micron and lower sized micro-droplets of water into chocolate, but that water is entirely “locked away.” That means it is totally invisible in every way and offers no functional benefit except fat reduction. The commercialization is only starting on these technologies, and the cost may never be very low.

9 Responses to “Chocolate and Water FAQ”

  1. Question about tempered chocolate using agave nectar sweetener.

    Hello John, I have been trying to figure out how to temper chocolate that has Agave as a sweetener. I went to a professional French pastry school where I learned how to make chocolate and when I ask them a question about using a liquid sweetener in chocolate and if it could then be tempered, they didn’t think it was possible. It appears that it is possible because of there are chocolate bars with agave which I have seen for sale online and they seem to be tempered. I haven’t contacted these companies because I doubt that they would give away their trade secrets, and would want me to buy their candy bars instead of making them myself, but I have my own ideas about the kind of chocolate that I want to make, which would be different than theirs. I have checked and there isn’t a crystallized form of Agave nectar. Might you know how I can temper chocolate sweetened with agave syrup and still have it come out being at a hard tempered state.

    I shouldn’t have sugar, which makes me ill, so I am trying to find an alternative that is healthy.

    Thanks very much for reading my e-mail, and if you don’t know the answer I’d appreciate it if you could lead me in the direction of somebody who you think does,

    Sincerely,

    Victoria Fuller

  2. Victoria,

    I have also seen these agave products and I don’t think they are actually tempered. To the best of my knowledge, there is no trade secret (then again, if it is secret, how would I know). They simply don’t bloom.

    I tend to agree with the assessment that you can’t temper with water present. It just doesn’t work. You might be able to use some of the suggestions above, and get a hard chocolate like product, but I am not sure just how worth the effort it is.

    I want to point out something that I hear a lot, and I think is worth thinking about. You don’t want ‘sugar’ because it makes you ill. Why I have to ask. ANY syrup has sugar. That is the definition of a syrup.

    Maybe you mean refined sugar. In that case, an organic unrefined sugar may be what you need. Just a thought.

  3. It could be that they used agave powder as any liquid/syrup can be spray dried to make a powder no ? Martin

  4. Hi Victor,
    I was wondering if you have had any success in figuring out how to temper chocolate sweetened with agave, as I’m on a similar mission myself! Any help would be greatly appreciated!
    Julie

  5. hi Martin, there is a dried powder of agave but this is essentially inulin, which is not sweet at all.

    Hey Victoria: have you ever used coconut sugar? i find it amazingly healthy and very yummy…they also have it in a syrup form (a company called “coconut secret”).

    enjoy everyone!

  6. I found I can use dry Stevia powder and mix it into unsweetened chocolate and it works great. I make chocolate chips for snacking and also used it in a Chocolate meringue pie where I mix the filling with chocolate and whipped cream.

  7. hi
    this guy is saying :
    250 ML water
    90 Gr. dark chocolate
    i did not try iy

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZy-v0nDLwM

  8. Love the website!!! I have a question, and I have been searching for it everywhere, I guess it is a million dollar one, I have seized chocolate with water like anyone else. It is possible to fix seized chocolate, with chemical agents or process, remove that extra water somehow, reverse the reaction? return the chocolate to the original state where it can be tempered again?. I do not mean add more water or fat like they suggest, this is not temper-able chocolate anymore in my view.

  9. Great question. Sadly, the answer is ‘it depends’. If it is just a little, and you can get it to flow somewhat in the melanger, you can try adding heat and lecithin. That might prove enough to bind and/or drive off the water. If it is like fudge, that is pretty well doomed.

Leave a Reply

Instagram

facebook.png



Articles and other Helpful pages

Alchemical Formulations
(Recipes)



alavert discount code 2012 buy purim youtube order septilin dosage hyaluronic acid discount dangers cheap toprol xl you gain weight order calcium carbonate uses in food mail order synthroid buy zanaflex in stores diclofenac gel discount for solar keratosis buy aricept francisco cheap premarin spray lantus vial discount code buy xxtra clean buy colchicine zealand buy aceon australia buy brand viagra in canada order anti fungal inflammatory cream order provigil canada cheap wellbutrin sr bipolar disorder cheap wellbutrin sr reviews order arizona mucho mango order propranolol prescription cheap relafen in usa buy maxalt korea buy cheap amoxil buy cholesterol lowering exercise routine order nexium 40 mg buy purinethol best place order naprosyn nedir cheap abilify reviews chloromycetin discount cheap effexor xr benefits cheap lisinopril buy apo prednisone metoclopramide discount code wellbutrin sr discount zyban cheap anti viral list of antivirus order ginette 35 mrp urispas discount programs buy himalaya purim online clindamycin gel discount card brand cialis discount from canada cheap dipyridamole glucuronide zyvox discount prescription order zyban online uk order clomid pills online buy prandin angeles cheap nizagara information unisom discount order glucotrol xl eq cheap trial erection packs 3 year order actoplus met name buy dostinex online australia trazodone discount card pravachol discount voucher buy rogaine 5 liquid cheap cialis super active plus reviews cheap allegra d 24 hour cheap diclofenac gel jonah complex buy reminyl farmaco cheap colchicine jicht buy glucotrol xl it works antivert discount voucher buy albenza online buy urispas legal cheap viagra plus mastercard buy bupropion sr how long to work cheap ralista tablets buy cialis kl buy viagra super active tried order clonidine in canada order weight loss zone order cialis professional sublingual cheap zyvox buy online order tamoxifen zealand cheap mircette lawsuit buy levitra plus qatar buy desyrel australia cheap finpecia goa buy luvox cr buy elavil in canada cheap provera questions cheap ventolin buy terramycin soluble powder order glucophage 1 gm every am order diclofenac online uk cheap effexor xr for hot flashes buy female cialis online cheap prinivil price buy female cialis australia buy zithromax thailand order revia zebeta discount purchase zanaflex online order levothroid prescription cheap zofran xanax cheap ortho tri cyclen for acne reviews order periactin pills cheap shuddha guggulu capsules buy lioresal uk order cialis jelly kamagra buy reglan side shatavari kalpa buy online buy diclofenac real cheap floxin bula buy dilantin cheap order midamor online cheap advair diskus generic order aciclovir adjustment order with depression cheap glucophage xr cheap cialis professional vs regular cheap relafen buy cheap hydrochlorothiazide india get avodart prescription cheap toradol dosage cheap baclofen cheap cialis super active dosage buy xenical for cheap buy viagra plus at walmart order brand advair diskus formulation cheap sinequan tablete wellbutrin sr discount experiences cheap vytorin a prescription order kesar mango online voltaren copay assistance buy orlistat hcl order glyset online buy ginette 35 and acne xenical discount card buy artane buy eurax online buy trental perth buy levitra plus thailand cheap brand levitra online buy nitroglycerin for cats cheap flagyl er tablets cheap v gel xcin cheap viagra levitra cialis pain relief discount back exercises cheap levitra uk cheap prednisone online mobic discount vouchers rxmeds hub order cialis professional online cheap amaryl zamiennik buy trazodone uk buy snovitra super power 80 mg cialis super active discount vs professional nizoral discount krasnodar buy brand viagra by paypal buy erythromycin online where to buy baytril for dogs rumalaya forte discount uses order buspar usa cheap etodolac price innopran xl discount uses buy propecia philippines buy antivert in stores buy ortho tri cyclen zebra case order brand cialis vs generic buy revatio approval buying valtrex online safe buy doxycycline veterinary female viagra discount are there buy medrol for dogs buy premarin cream online lanoxin discount prescription buy zetia rx rumalaya forte discount himalaya products order zithromax qatar buy revia bula buy hydrochlorothiazide japan buy elocon you cheap toprol xl ingredients order vytorin canada cheap anxiety pills where to buy baytril for reptiles order pravachol by mail discount for flovent buy alavert wholesale acticin discount voucher order cialis super active info order zovirax illegal order allergies cheap advair diskus rinse mouth after use cheap artane rent cheap prevacid otc cheap lithium golf batteries hyaluronic acid discount on skin buy anti fungal remedies ortho tri cyclen discount questions imitrex discount buy men;s health zero excuses workout buy lexapro brand name cheap relafen version buy emsam houston buy revatio tablete lexapro discount coupon manufacturers order chloromycetin information order viagra sublingual spray buy augmentin tablets cheap flagyl a prescription kamagra discount code order hytrin dose cheap revatio products cheap rumalaya gel benefits cheap xenical orlistat cheap voveran sr wiki buy anti fungal xylitol order florinef cheapest ranitidine uk buy prandin generic revatio discount card order cialis and viagra order reminyl uses buy hydrochlorothiazide korea exelon corporate discounts order adalat episode buy purinethol online cheap brand viagra the uk cheap imitrex order skelaxin together cheap actoplus met offer strattera to buy buy anti fungal lozenges cheap bentyl reviews buy hydrochlorothiazide in thailand buy propecia online europe order propecia uk actonel discount program cheap zebeta place buy cheap makita lithium ion batteries cheap viagra sublingual immunotherapy brand cialis discount name vs generic buy lasix over the counter cheap generic kamagra order anti fungal foot cream buy hydrea where can cheap cleocin gel rosacea cheap differin lotion order valtrex europe cheap azulfidine monitoring buy dipyridamole can cheap azulfidine ra buy viagra soft brisbane order cytotec you order casodex uses order v gel za bolec(ine v mis(icah zaditor discount vouchers order chloromycetin antibiotic order toprol xl recall hyaluronic acid discount hair cheap danazol buy cheapest generic avodart cheap actoplus met prescribing information cheap ali g costume buy doxycycline vietnam buy xenical diet pills online buy cipro can buy flagyl in us cheap xenical nz cymbalta discounts with insurance proscar discount card order female viagra how it works diclofenac gel discount usa buy nizagara online uk buy brand viagra delivery order toprol xl queensland tick typhus buy trazodone online buy terramycin line cialis super active discount hub order cheap ponstel reviews buy pantoprazole in uk cheap kamagra gold review levitra professional discount rezept cheap cialis soft how to take order lisinopril buy kamagra oral jelly usa cheap zovirax a prescription cheap cafergot price buy xalatan real cholesterol lowering discount high lasuna discount hyaluronic acid discount powder sleep aid discount up and up buying zovirax ointment buy female cialis japan order finalization cheap advair diskus therapeutic class cheap viagra plus soft tabs buy proscar australia isoniazid discount card cheap kamagra oral jelly xenia cholesterol lowering discount cookbooks buy antivert legal buy premarin australia generic viagra sublingual order lipitor buy suhagra dosage flagyl er discount zentrale buy ginette 35 safe order pain relief removal of wisdom teeth buy amantadine pills buy urispas australia cialis jelly discount generic buy cheap dianabol tablets order effexor xr benefits buy requip uses buy erythromycin in uk cheap lopressor cheap mentat ds syrup benefits buy xalatan korea buy rogaine 2 malaysia buy viagra oral jelly cheap venlor antidepressant buy triamterene rx buy clomid philippines rogaine 2 discount vs 5 order desyrel india buy brand proscar erexin v discount mega opinie roxithromycin discounts order remeron pharmacy sleep aids discount herbal brand cialis discount name buy online female viagra discount card order calcium carbonate generic name buy viagra professional ge'ne'rique 100 mg cheap muscle relaxant in pregnancy cheap venlor buy kamagra chewable soft buy januvia you buy arthritis pain medication cheap pilex express order diclofenac gel jonah complex buy avodart reviews buy aceon online etodolac discount prescription order lotensin dosage inderal discount coupon cheap rogaine 2 weeks buy viagra cialis online canada zyprexa coupons deals buy nitrofurantoin rx zovirax discount get cheap rocaltrol wiki cheap viagra jelly in uk order oral lamisil cheap wellbutrin sr cut in half tenormin discount buy buy valtrex medication buy alli pills canada buy ortho tri cyclen kariva buy requip at walmart buy lasix cheap online provigil law and order svu grifulvin v discount suspension dosage buy cymbalta canada buy diclofenac japan buy blum minipress p buy kamagra oral jelly vanilla synthroid discount card order brand advair diskus bronchodilator order motrin cheap shatavari kalpa buy capoten philippines erexin v discount opinie forum buy cheap periactin online buy triamterene from uk buy ginette 35 price in india where can i buy lipitor generic order starlix dosage order cialis free overnight delivery kamagra gold discount kamagra order alli loss pills buy ginette 35 for birth control cheap apcalis sx nebenwirkungen order arava in canada cheap rental limos hair loss discount gluten order imuran in canada order didronel mail buy colchicine tablets buy kamagra with paypal uk buy zovirax cold sore cream lopid discount programs cheap penegra medicine cheap v gel jell buy female cialis from canadian pharmacy buy cialis jelly mg order weight loss vacations buy saw palmetto receding hairline cheap nitroglycerin in usa buy men;s health hairstyles order cefixime wiki order viagra super active kaufen buy didronel from canada cheap antabuse very requip discount pharmacy buy retino-a cream 0,025 buy graphic tees cheap glucotrol xl rxlist buy maxalt mlt cialis discount card cvs buy viagra super active long does cheap diclofenac gel cost buy voveran sr tab buy female viagra gel buy luvox xr order a bank statement buy brand name propecia hair loss discount from chemo cialis soft discount diferencia buy didronel online canada buy dutas place buy elocon buy viagra super active test buy flagyl for bv buy revatio dosage cipro xr prices lantus discount number buy viagra super active france wellbutrin sr discount nightmares order sinemet nausea men;s health discount online buy phenergan liquid buy confidor online cheap viagra plus cheap rental places buy actos humanos order zyvox india order prazosin uk buy avodart veterinary cheap lariam online buy levitra super active forum cheap viagra professional vs professional buy zithromax next day delivery buy didronel pills buy prandin vietnam cheap danazol nedir calan discount code cheap kamagra oral jelly quoi buy men;s health issues bystolic prescription savings card cheap mircette acne plendil discount cheap atorlip 10 f 10 side effects buy ortho tri cyclen lo online cheap buy cytotec usa cheap effexor xr night sweats buy l tryptophan joint pain geriforte syrup discount price order florinef mail mango discount coupon dostinex discount get buy real kamagra methotrexate discount order lisinopril from canada female viagra discount it work periactin discount buy tricor 145 mg cheap cleocin gel buy female cialis johannesburg cheap female cialis www.cheap cialis.com buy aciclovir australia order cleocin gel and breastfeeding order adalat zaandam order remeron rx cheap cholesterol lowering diet order serevent prescription order real cialis online cheap procardia headache order erectile dysfunction lisinopril order relafen reviews cleocin gel discount dose order propranolol zealand cheap cymbalta side innopran xl discount for tremors order cialis professional brand cheap prandin uk buy cheap premarin online order tretinoin 0 05 italok buy tretinoin 0 05 usp buy brand viagra online australia zoloft to buy online hair loss discount medication order anti fungal laundry detergent cheap viagra with free shipping viagra jelly discount karma cheap vpxl ingredients cialis jelly discount kamagra order innopran xl gain cheap betoptic drops buy carafate real cheap status anxiety wallets buy micronase can order pain relief when in labour effexor xr cost without insurance buy real hoodia order hair loss causes